Piracy of the Middle Ages Compared to the 'Golden Age of Piracy'
When people think of
pirates, they often think of the buccaneers that plundered the seas from
roughly 1650 to 1730. This time period is also known as the ‘golden age of
piracy’. These pirates included the infamous Blackbeard, Henry Morgan, and
Captain Kidd. However, piracy has existed long before these swashbucklers. In
Medieval Europe, many towns were terrorized by pirates, but eventually pirates
began to be used as mercenaries and privateers. The pirates of the middle ages,
and the tactics that they used can be compared and contrasted to the piracy
that took place in the late 17th to mid 18th centuries. This comparison is
important because it shows how many of the tactics used during the ‘golden age
of piracy’ were actually taken from preexisting methods of piracy.
The
Middle Ages spanned from the 5th century to the 15th century, and the first
acts of piracy that can be seen in this period were the Vikings, who, beginning
in the 8th century, would dock their ships on land and attack communities near
the ocean. These towns would be pillaged, and many civilians would be brutally
raped and killed. The violence and unpredictability of the Vikings stirred fear
throughout many coastal communities, many of whom would not even put up a fight
because they were so afraid. The most famous of these groups was the Narentines
who raided for profit and were very active in the slave trade. They would often
capture many civilians to be later sold as slaves. Every person on the ship was
viewed as an equal and got an equal share of the wealth, with the exception of
the owner of the ship who got a slightly bigger share. The captain of the ship
was viewed as the first among equals.
Many
characteristics of Viking pirates can be seen as similar to the pirates during
the ‘golden age of piracy’. This is especially true of the way the ship was
organized. Both saw equality among shipmates and an equal share of the loot
that was important in maintaining order and preventing mutiny. While Vikings
mostly attacked towns instead of other ships, the tactics used in both cases
were characterized by extreme violence that incited fear into many. Similarly,
both era’s saw pirates that were mainly motivated for monetary gain. In both
cases piracy was viewed as an alternative to trading, and more economically
rewarding.
The
age of the Vikings started to wane in the 11th century but was replaced by a
mercenary style of Piracy. Waring European countries started hiring naval
mercenaries. However, when their mercenary contracts were over, and they were
out of work, many mercenaries would resort to piracy. These pirates would
target and attack trade ships, making trade impossible in certain sea channels.
The use of mercenaries of the sea is viewed as the predecessor to privateering,
which is considered to have started in the 13th century. Privateering involved
a country giving licenses to ships to attack foreign vessels. The profits of
these attacks were then split between the king and the privateers. However,
many privateers turned to piracy and simply kept the goods for themselves as
well as attacked ships that were supposed to be considered neutral or under the
authority of the country that they were hired to. European countries could not
control the people to whom they had granted licenses.
The
beginning of the ‘golden age of piracy’ was characterized by similar problems.
European countries would hire privateers to attack enemy ships in American
waters, but many of these privateers would attack ships that they were not
authorized too, and were often more oriented to making money than to actually
help the country to which they were hired. The breadth of similarities between
piracy of the Middle Ages and piracy under the ‘golden age of piracy’ is
exceedingly interesting. Why did European countries continue to use tactics
that were out of their control? Why is the ‘golden age of piracy’ so revered
when roughly the same events were occuring hundreds of years earlier? What
makes the ‘golden age of piracy’ so special?
http://ic.galegroup.com/ic/suic/ReferenceDetailsPage/ReferenceDetailsWindow?failOverType=&query=&prodId=SUIC&windowstate=normal&contentModules=&display-query=&mode=view&displayGroupName=Reference&limiter=&currPage=&disableHighlighting=false&displayGroups=&sortBy=&search_within_results=&p=SUIC&action=e&catId=&activityType=&scanId=&documentId=GALE%7CCX1931000039&source=Bookmark&u=nysl_ro_hilton&jsid=4824226cf1e8f25dcfd0527376d3d2ee
I really appreciate the connection that you make in this post between the golden age of piracy and the vikings. People tend to overlook the fact that piracy was not first established during the golden age of piracy and I think this connection to past examples of piracy is helpful when attempting to understand the motives of the 17th century pirates and their tactics. The idea that the golden age of piracy is almost a mimicry of earlier forms of piracy is intriguing, and I think you argued that connection really well. Along with this, the question of "why should the golden age of piracy be so revered?" truly puts into perspective the idea that piracy is not new and that the golden age should not be considered some spectacular event when similar events were occurring hundreds of years ago. One question that I would ask is, why do you think that the pirates during the golden age of piracy used similar methods as the ones that were used before? Do you believe that this is because it was the easiest way to gain economic control during the 17th century or was it because the vikings had been so successful just hundreds of years ago that the 17th century pirates wanted to recreate a similar reign? Regardless of the answer, great job!
ReplyDeleteThank you so much for you comments! I would say that the use of privateers and mercenaries of the sea in medieval piracy reflected the use of privateers in North American waters because of the fact that, while privateering had its downsides, it was still a helpful way of waging war on one's enemies. The main difference was where the privateering and piracy took place. I dont know if pirates during the golden age of piracy purposefully used similar tactics as of those as the vikings. It could be, not a knowledge of the tactics of the vikings, but a universal and timeless understanding of the power of violence and fear tactics in furthering a political or economic goal.
ReplyDeleteYour main point is spot on, the tactics used by pirates in the 'Gold Age' stemmed from their learnt behavior that implored tactics mimicking preexisting and historical pirate actions. The paper overall was well written. You explained throughout your prompt previous pirates and their actions, exposing their presence within the pirates during the Golden Age. However, I wish you played around more with terrorism, clearly linking it to either the monetary gain these pirates sought, or any motive you find fitting. Also, I think you could use the three questions you posed at the very end of the paper somewhere within the body of your essay, so you get a chance to clearly explain their relevance/importance. They are strong questions that I feel if answered would sure strengthen your paper.
ReplyDelete